(10/16/09) - After intensive negotiations
with the US EPA and the Ohio EPA, the City of Akron has reached a proposed agreement on
the combined sewer overflow litigation. The parties have informed the district court they
have reached a compromise and will seek the approval of Akron City Council and the
attorneys general of the United States and the State of Ohio in the upcoming weeks. The
court case has been stayed until November 17th to allow time for the approval process to
proceed.Throughout the negotiations, Akron had been urging the US EPA to allow it to
proceed to improve the sewers in a staged approach, instead of trying to identify the
specific projects years in advance of their construction. Instead, the parties have agreed
upon the methods for conducting the studies and evaluations which will be used to
determine the specific projects to be constructed. Under the proposed order Akron will
have 12 months to update its long term control plan for the sewers.
The City will construct two additional sewer separation projects within four years and
three others within the following four years. Akron agreed to upgrade its wastewater
treatment plant by increasing its secondary treatment capacity from 110 to 130 million
gallons per day within 5-7 years.
Although the US and State of Ohio routinely require huge civil penalties and had
initially demanded tens of millions of dollars in penalties, the fine imposed in this case
is actually very small compared to their original request. The City will pay $300,000 to
the federal government and $200,000 to the State of Ohio. In addition, the City agreed to
provide funds for a supplemental environmental project which will be capped at $900,000.
That project will be the removal of the Route 82 dam near Brecksville.
In reaching the agreement, the US and Ohio EPAs recognized Akron had made substantial
investments in excess of $53,000,000 in upgrading its sewer system since 1993.
Improvements include, but are not limited to, construction of the Cuyahoga Street Storage
Facility (CSO Rack 40) that captures more than 36% of the combined sewer overflow volume
from the system.
The following is a statement from Mayor Don Plusquellic regarding the consent decree
with the US and Ohio EPAs:
"Akron began in 1994 on the studies necessary to make logical decisions on how to
overcome the problem of inheriting combined sewers that were last built in 1938.
Despite the agreement we reached with the State of Ohio seven years ago, the US EPA was
especially unreasonable in applying rational, affordable standards to our situation.
We fought to keep costs down for our citizens and even gave in to federal demands, in
particular on the issue of fines, because of the huge cost of litigation.
We still believe we have adhered to the regulations and were actually prevented by the
US EPA from proceeding to do projects to clean up the river since 2002.
But with this agreement, we will finally be able to start cleaning the water going into
the Cuyahoga River rather than paying attorneys to argue with bureaucrats in Washington
who seem to care very little about the hard working people in our community who have to
pay for this."
END